Entertainment, as the critic Ned Rorem has pointed out, confirms rather than challenges. One might comment that there are entertainers and there are blue-blood artists but that the two don't often coincide in popular music.
When they do -- and the temporal clause should be stressed -- you've good reason to believe you're in the presence of something special and rarefied: genius as opposed to talent.
As far as I know, nobody has ever asked for their money back at a Joni Mitchell concert, and that's a fair enough endorsement of good entertainment for you.
At the same time you'd be a pretty boneheaded mutt not to feel challenged by her presence and the splendid mystery of her music.
There's nothing equivocal about shivers bristling on the spine as she hovers into view upon the state and that effortless, crystal voice begins to play upon the sensibilities.
Joni Mitchell is disturbing in a very real way because after watching and listening to her for a while you start thinking she's not just a woman, she's WOMAN, embodying all male desires and expectations.
Small wonder then that a legion of very well-known men have been sufficiently drawn by the siren's call to jump in headfirst after her. So this is the meaning of worship? Like the White Goddess of mythology she beckons, elusive, virginal and not a little awe-inspiring. It must be a trifle terrifying to know you appear that perfect.
Crap, she'd probably reply, because after all she's human and with a well-developed sense of humour, too.
Idolatry is fun but it gets a little wearing after the initial enslavement. Her biggest problem in recent years, one might argue, has been to convince us that she's not Lady Madonna, children at her feet, and not for that matter a latter-day Joan Baez for the pure of heart.
Still, the mystique persists, and it's not just confined to male fantasies and communicants. Without her ever having made much outright comment on it, ardent feminists inevitably tend to see her as the patron saint of Lib, finding all the justification they need in the barely oblique autobiography of her albums.
Therein lie exposed all her innermost thoughts and feelings, her psychic and sexual wrestlings with the male species that she's at pains never to divulge in any journalistic context. A true paradox.
For her part she retires to some private world, there to view the outside happenings with a deep and discerning detachment. She laughs a lot -- girlishly, even -- but I should think, from the few occasions I've seen her away from the public platform, she's careful to keep her guard up.
For a woman so obviously sensitised by her experiences it must be necessary; flippant posturing and brassy panache are not weapons in her armoury. Ms. Midler and Ms. Streisand find no echoes.
Dory Previn can turn it into tragi-comedy, play Woody Allen from the safety of the psycho-analyst's couch, but Joni always makes us feel her soul is on the line. It's all rather confusing for a mere mortal male: the protective instinct met head on by her sensual authoritativeness.
But quite evidently, something has changed of late, for her concert appearances such as Saturday's at London's New Victoria theatre, are now much less solemnly artistic than in the past.
She no longer even resembles the old coffee-house folksinger, with long blonde hair brushing shoulders and eyebrows; it's curled and finessed, and her cheeks glow with make-up.
Her manager, Elliott Roberts, laughs as you remark upon this. "Well," he says, "she's a woman!" Undeniably, but the effect is somehow less ethereal. And then there's a band around her for the first time, Tom Scott's L.A. Express, filling the emptiness and silence between the grand piano, the acoustic guitar and Appalachian harp.
Joni actually rocking out with some funky chicken, Joni closing the show with Annie Ross's little exercise in lingual humour, "Twisted." Joni cracking wry jokes. Joni elaborating long stories to her audience as preludes to her songs, and even -- for her pains -- coming in for the affectionate rebuke of "speed freak" from some guy out there in the crowd.
Joni, finally, somewhat more in evidence as the entertainer, as well as the artist, and suddenly the sharp realisation for this listener of the gap in time and emotion between a song's composition and its public performance, and in particular the extent of her professional skill in pulling out that original emotion. Yes, she was as great as ever, but her performance was doubly interesting for the way the new situation threw light on her artistic functioning.
In "The Same Situation" she muffed the second stanza, stopped and laughed broadly, then explained via the piano how she was confusing the particular passage with a new melody she was working on; eventually she went back to the song and performed it with such conviction and sincerity that it might have been the freshest thing she'd written.
She preceded "People's Parties" by a wickedly intelligent and humourous rap about the incident from which it sprang, complete with dissertation on the significance of Nixon's facial expressions. And then she illuminated a song about her mistrust of materialism, together with critics and the music industry, with a completely evocative tale about ascetic existence in British Columbia and the humanistic qualities of the arbutus tree that grows there!
These virtual self-parables and the evident disregard for the private mask made her more accessible than she's ever seemed. Contrast this attitude with the incommunicado stance of Dylan, the male artist whose stature she most closely approaches, and one can't help but feel her performances gain from it.
On the other hand, perhaps, by featuring a band, she never built up and sustained the deepest intimacy of atmosphere that she's often achieved before with just an acoustic and a piano. But it was time for her to devise a new mode of presentation, and in the L.A. Express she couldn't have found finer instruments.
If anything they helped to concentrate attention on the arranging side of her talents. For instance, that usually delicate song "Woodstock" was here translated into a piece of funk, with snapping snare work from John Guerin and the deep, churning Fender of Max Bennett. It didn't quite suit the lyrics, but what WERE you to do with a four-year old hippie anthem?
The LA. Express perform a similar kind of function for Joni as the Section did for James Taylor: they're both an independent unit and a backup band.
But the Section don't have quite the same degree of intensity and virtuosity. As the L.A. Express went through a short warm-up set for Joni it gradually began to dawn upon us that they weren't just B-movie filler material for the great extravaganza. Not that the presence of Robben Ford, the guitarist last seen here with Jimmy Witherspoon, would suggest that.
Though the context didn't allow for much in the way of real soloing, his gifts were always apparent in deft touches and complements, and his enthusiasm -- his body jiggling around and long hair flapping -- was infectious.
Roger Kelleway on electric piano had one roaring solo on "Raised on Robbery," and Tom Scott played a variety of parts on saxes, flute and clarinet -- a lovely, wistful sign-off on "For Free" -- but the essence of their role was its selflessness, just as their inclinations were obviously towards jazz. And for Joni's music they were perfect, gilding the lily at exactly the right junctures and taking the edge off the occasional austerity of her live performance.
Now, too, Joni seems able to laugh at herself more -- at the public image of her. In "For Free" she could slip in a sly reference to not just one or two but "16 gentlemen" lovers, an indication of her self-confidence and maturity. Again, the gentle humour of her public self, the optimism of her onstage presence, contrasted with the disquiet and virtual despair of her records. Ultimately, you're forced to admit, she remains a cool and beautiful enigma, all the more so with a new style of performance that stresses her easiness of manner.
For Saturday's performance did, indeed, confirm and challenge one's feelings about her, and at the risk of being accused of critical overkill, I'd say she's just about the most fascinating and involving artist of the times. She's found a uniquely personal way of transcending the rock idiom whilst retaining the rock audience. What's more she's undisputedly an artist of the future, who's yet to hit anything like a peak. She's got everything she needs, she's an artist . . . she don't look back.
Copyright protected material on this website is used in accordance with 'Fair Use', for the purpose of study, review or critical analysis, and will be removed at the request of the copyright owner(s). Please read Notice and Procedure for Making Claims of Copyright Infringement.
Added to Library on January 9, 2000. (6262)
Log in to make a comment