Library of Articles

  • Library: Articles

Old-Fashioned Love Songs Print-ready version

by Robert Hilburn
Los Angeles Times
May 10, 2000

JONI MITCHELL'S latest album, released early this year, is a career vacation of sorts for one of the most acclaimed singer-songwriters of the modern pop eranot that the album is in any way a casual affair.

Discouraged by the state of society and the reality of the conglomerate-dominated music business these days, Mitchellwho plays the Concord Pavilion on Saturdaywanted to step back and do something that totally enchanted her.

The result, "Both Sides Now" (named for one of her first hits), is a collection of standards woven together ambitiously to reflect on the early glow and final ashes of relationships. The albumfeaturing such vintage tunes as "Stormy Weather," as well as two of her own songswas recorded with the London Symphony Orchestra. The arrangements, by Vince Mendoza, evoke in places the signature sounds of such jazz masters as Duke Ellington and Gil Evans.

Some listeners may lament the absence of more Mitchell material, but Mitchell herself is so pleased with working with the orchestra that she is now planning to record an entire album of her own old songs this way.

In an interview, Mitchell, 56, speaks about the album, the music business and her own latest relationship.

Why didn't you want to do an album of new Joni Mitchell songs?

Because my music is drawn from my feelings, and I just didn't want to be a social commentator at this time. I feel these are difficult times, and we all need to develop some type of . . . discipline or soul nourishment or strength to deal with all the problems facing the world, problems that are coming to a head in every department. Even I wouldn't want to hear an album of that stuff right now. I just feel my point of view is too realistic, and reality is too bleak.

What about the state of pop music these days?

I think it is in a horrible state. I don't even think of it as music anymore but just the "ic" business. It's "icky" because the "muse" has gone out of it. The divinity that it once contained is gone.


Part of it is the capitalistic feeding frenzy. Music today is viewed by corporations as simply a sales line that is either going up or down. . . . It's just a graph for shareholders. We don't even know who is at the top anymore of all these corporations. There used to be the chairman, who was as high up in a company as you could go, but now the chairman is just a pissant in the larger corporation. The other thing I notice is that music is being made by committees. I received a lifetime-achievement award recently from Sony, and they played the year's big songs. They were horrible, one after the other. . . . And when people got up to receive the awards, you could see why: There were four to eight people getting up, and sometimes there was a businessman among them. A committee cannot make a work of art. Art is created by one person or two people working in unity.

So how did you get enthusiasm to make the new record?

I decided to do it after singing "Stormy Weather" at the Don Henley benefit in Los Angeles in 1998. It was liberating just to sing someone else's music. Plus, I wanted to make an album that represented a romantic journey with musical ideas culled from some of the most creative music of the 20th century.

What about the romantic journey?

It's the one we've all been on. First, you are smittenwhich is the first song, "You're My Thrill," which was a Billie Holiday recording. Then you go through facets of pleading and making concessions along the way. Then the romantic love goes away, and the album ends with "Both Sides Now," which says you don't know love at all.

The album brings us to the debate over songwriting traditions the pre-World War II tradition, and the more introspective and complex tradition that you and Bob Dylan helped create. How do you rate those traditions?

It's interesting, because "Both Sides Now," which was one of the first songs I wrote, clearly has one foot in each camp . . . old songwriting and new songwriting. The old songs were very symbolic. They used the weather a lot because they were coming out of an agrarian culture. There was a tremendous amount of references to the sky to denote emotion -- "You Are My Sunshine," "Stormy Weather." But there was very little of the intimate soul-scraping of the new tradition.

Let's go back to the album's theme. What have you learned about romantic love over the years?

Romantic love is a trick of nature, fueled by anxiety and insecurity. The moment the thing is secured, it dissipates. It's a trick of nature to get us to procreate. There are other kinds of love, however, that are more stable. Romantic love goes out. The Sinatra song "I Wish I Were in Love Again" deals with it well. . . . "The quick toboggan when you reach the heights.". . . It's all downhill. But you end up saying, "Oh, I want another hit of it." It's kind of like drug addiction.

So how about yourself, are you optimistic about lasting relationships? Are you in a relationship?

I have a very good relationship with a man from my hometown. He still lives there. We get together and travel. We are old enough where we are comfortable with a long-distance romance. In our youth, I don't think we could have done it. It's a growing, flowering relationship of nearly seven years. Plus, I have really good friends whom I love. I have cats I love. I have a daughter I love. I have grandchildren I love. These are all different kinds of love, but lasting love.

Copyright protected material on this website is used in accordance with 'Fair Use', for the purpose of study, review or critical analysis, and will be removed at the request of the copyright owner(s). Please read Notice and Procedure for Making Claims of Copyright Infringement.

Added to Library on May 17, 2000. (9037)


Log in to make a comment