Library of Articles

  • Library: Articles

Dylan, Mitchell create new moods Print-ready version

by David Heller
The Vidette (Illinois State University)
January 31, 1974
Original article: PDF

During those sizzling 60's, rock music circles traditionally recognized a supreme triumvirate as leaders of a culture. The Beatles, the Rolling Stones and Bob Dylan were the gods of the times, and were responsible for turning around the heads of an entire generation.

But as the 60's drew to an end, so did the Big Three: the Beatles ended that scene after grossing somewhere around $100 million, and Bob Dylan threw away the mantle of folk prophet and went to Nashville for some love songs, leaving the Stones at the top for no other reason than that they were still around.

Now, in the directionless 70's, the winds bring rumors that a Beatles reconciliation is at hand. And lo and behold, Dylan himself has hit the road in one of the most talked about tours in a decade. Along with the tour an album was promised, and about a week ago, "Planet Waves" (Asylum 7E-1003), a collaboration with The Band, came out, and it ' seems pretty safe to say that Dylan is finally back.

The feeling one gets from "Planet Waves" is like familiarity, almost a deja vu effect. Dylan's voice is in fine form, and The Band's work is remarkable, bringing back the style of "Like a Rolling Stone Positively 4th Street." The production is remarkably clear and tight, presenting Dylan in his best light all the way through.

The songs themselves are a whole different matter. There seems to be a trace of every phase he's ever gone through lyrically a lot of the love song style from his Morning" George Harrison period, a hint of the protest song, and a little bit of "John Wesley Harding."

The album opens with a slightly country tune, "On a Night Like This," just a light little romance, and from there goes down to a mournful "Going Going Gone." The song is punctuated by Robbie Robertson's slide guitar, which, like the rest of the instrumental tracks, is laid back low enough to be effective without taking a bit of the spotlight from the singer.

The total album is divided pretty evenly between a light-hearted Dylan and a more pensive, almost saddened personality. It's the slower numbers that leave the biggest impression, for they contain the lyrics that call to mind the Dylan of '65.

"Dirge" contains the passage "I can't recall a useful thing you ever did for me, but pat me on the head one time when I was on my knees." His most biting lyric ever, "Positively 4th Street" is brought back, but the primal scream of that song is tempered here into a love song filled with a shocked sadness. In "Wedding Song," Dylan actually mentions his past words, saying determination, "It's never been my duty to remake the world at large, nor is it my intention to sound the battle charge."

And that is why this album is so important. Not only is it one hell of an album musically, but we finally have something to judge the Dylan of today with, and aside from a passing reference, Dylan seems to want that judgement based on today alone, with no thought of yesterday. For a man with so much power to start all over again is highly noble, and something we should respect. The man has given us the album we've been waiting for for years - maybe we can start again with him.

Like Dylan when he came on stage with an electric band in 1966, Joni Mitchell stands a very real chance of alienating a whole field of fans with her new effort, "Court and Spark" (Asylum 7E-1001). An extension of her last, "For the Roses," she has tried to make the transition of styles go a little easy. The change may be a little too radical for her followers to accept, even though the crowd reaction at her U of I concert a couple weeks ago was one of the best reactions I've ever seen for anything. Like Dylan, she all of a sudden began working with a full rock band.

Though the first half of her concert was not as successful as it could have been, by the end the crowd loved it. Part of the reason may have been the prevalence of material off "Court and Spark," which no one had heard yet - however any doubts about that material were quickly dispelled after hearing the actual album.

"For the Roses" hinted at a classier Joni than the one who sang folk songs in Laurel Canyon a few years ago. A little flash in the arrangements, and the first drums ever heard with Joni Mitchell's voice were there. In light of "Roses," this album is the possible follow-up. There may be cries of anguish from the purists, actually, "Court and Spark" is an excellent album.

Her melancholy lyrics are intact, although the traumatic affairs that filled her past albums (Graham Nash, James Taylor) no longer dominate. Her powers as a poet come through without the emotional edge that shadowed her words: "Still I sent up my prayer, wondering where it had to go, with heaven full of astronauts and the Lord on death row..." she comments. And "Car On a Hill" is nothing less than total musical poetry, with a stunning arrangement.

The rock aspect isn't overbearing in the studio as it was on stage, but the influence is there. A jazz-style drum fills out the background, with the addition of strings and woodwinds scattered about. An almost tired orchestration appears on "Down to You," but it grows into a beautiful theme that continues the flow of the album.

Two outstanding cuts - "Raised on Robbery" and "Twisted" present a new Joni Mitchell. On the former she just out and out rocks, surprisingly it works. "Twisted" is a jazz tune with a sense of humour that ends the album with a flourish.

The only words to describe "Court and Spark" are superlatives: beautiful, stunning, perfection, and on and on. But maybe the words Joni Mitchell would suffice.

The records reviewed on this page were loaned to the Vidette by Student Stores, 115 North St., where they are currently available.

This article has been viewed 345 times since being added on March 1, 2019.

Copyright protected material on this website is used in accordance with 'Fair Use', for the purpose of study, review or critical analysis, and will be removed at the request of the copyright owner(s). Please read Notice and Procedure for Making Claims of Copyright Infringement.

Comments on Dylan, Mitchell create new moods

Comment using your Facebook profile, or by registering at this site.

You must be registered and log in to add a permanently indexed comment.

Facebook comments