I was at the H. R. MacMillan Space Centre to celebrate a birthday, of sorts - the 50th anniversary of Joni Mitchell's 1976 album Hejira. The Space Centre partnered with the UK-based company Pitchblack Playback, "the world's biggest deep listening event," for a listening session with a straightforward aim: you take your seat, the lights go out, and you listen to the album in full.
The first time I heard Hejira, the audio quality was pretty much in the pits. This was 2023, when Mitchell's catalogue was unavailable on Spotify in protest of the platform's promotion of podcasts that spread misinformation about the COVID-19 pandemic. So in my Orchard Commons dorm, I'd listen to her music on YouTube on my laptop browser. Despite this, the album's open tunings and stories of the open road haunted and enchanted me, and Joni's jazzy travelogue soundtracked the remainder of a turbulent first year.
I knew I'd have a good time at the Space Centre, if only because I was listening to one of my favourite albums - but I was curious (and a tiny bit skeptical) about what listening to the album in this setting could offer me.
Pitchblack Playback has been hosting listening sessions since 2016, when founder Ben Gomori was inspired by attending an album preview at a movie theatre in London's Soho district. "You came and sat and had a preview of the album, and they had some visuals on the screen," Gomori said. "I was really taken with the experience and the focused listening. I'd never done that before, in a public setting anyway, and I wanted to replicate that and bring it to the public."
A friend of Gomori's suggested that holding the sessions in the dark would enhance the experience after seeing a production of Not I, a play by the absurdist playwright Samuel Beckett. Not I takes place in near-complete darkness, with a spotlight illuminating only the actor's mouth.
Pitchblack Playback has hosted events in Vancouver before, but it was their first time partnering with the Space Centre. The Planetarium Star Theatre hosted three listening sessions on Nov. 5, each celebrating the anniversary of an iconic album: Loveless by My Bloody Valentine, A Seat at the Table by Solange, and, of course, Hejira. They'll be hosting more sessions at Lobe Studio in Strathcona, playing Phil Collins' Face Value on Nov. 19 and 22 and Bon Iver's 22, A Million on Dec. 13.
"[Planetariums are] acoustically-treated, they're completely dark and blackout-able. They usually have good sound," Gomori said. "We like spaces where you can be kind of immersed in a bubble of sound, and it's not just coming from the front."
The planetarium theatre is no stranger to music - Michael Unger, the Space Centre's director of programming and community engagement,informed me they've been running their Pink Floyd laser show since the 1970s, and they host live music, dance, and drag shows in the space. "I've always seen this space as a great place to listen to music," Unger said. "Over the years, as I became program coordinator, I certainly wanted to bring that back to this space."
But laser shows take full advantage of the planetarium's state-of-the-art projection technology. An event that eschewed the visual entirely was uncharted territory.
I stuck around for Unger's soundcheck, trying out various seats in the planetarium to find out for myself where the audio would be crispest (and loudest) while he tested different volumes. The Planetarium Star Theatre has a surround sound system, and because it's a round room, sitting in a different seat could give you an entirely different experience of the album. I found that the sound was best toward the middle of the theatre: you were closest to the speakers there - if you chose a seat near the back, the noise of the planetarium's fans could be overpowering.
Each ticket to a Pitchblack Playback event comes with a black cotton eye mask emblazoned with the company's name and logo. Venues are required to keep emergency exit lighting on during listening sessions in case of emergencies, so the masks help audiences immerse themselves in complete darkness if they so choose.
When the doors opened, I settled into a second-row seat. Just before the lights went out, Unger came out to introduce the show and talk about the Space Centre's arts and culture programming. I saw several people jump out of their seats when an announcement from Pitchblack blared over the speakers. Then, I slipped my eye mask on and settled in for 52 minutes of Joni.
Immediately, I could appreciate why Unger says the planetarium is a great space for music. While there was slight distortion at times, the impression that Joni Mitchell was singing right in my ear made up for it, and I could feel Jaco Pastorius's iconic bass lines reverberate in my chest - a far cry from my days of listening on YouTube. But I found myself feeling a bit bored and distracted during the first few songs. I had expected to feel a strong connection to the music, to be carried away by it; even though I felt the impact of the sound physically, what I experienced was a strange distance. I realized I was waiting for a transcendent experience, and when it didn't come right away, I was disappointed.
But I realized quickly that the experience would be exactly, and only, what I made of it. An event like that is meant to challenge its audience, not relax them - if you're looking to relax, stay home and do it for free. Once I began to treat it like an intellectual exercise, I began noticing and responding to things I'd never paid any thought to in the dozens of times I've listened to this album. It helps that Hejira is a very imagistic album, and giving it the entirety of my focus helped me reflect on and connect images I'd only considered in the abstract before.
Why had I never attended to lyrics like "Pawn shops glitter like gold tooth caps / In the grey decay / They chew the last few dollars off / Old Beale Street's carcass / Carrion and mercy" in "Furry Sings the Blues"? I must have heard those words a hundred times before, but had only ever considered how pretty they sounded sitting in the planetarium. In the days since the listening session, I keep pausing to think about those pawn shops as teeth eating away at the former glory of a famous blues neighbourhood. Or the drums in the album's title track, played by Bobbye Hall, which are faint to the point of fading away at times but add an ineffable richness to the track - I came away wondering what was wrong with me that I'd never given the percussion a second thought.
In the end, I did have a profound experience, but not exactly the effortless rapture I'd expected. It's completely possible that someone would be carried away by the music, although I wasn't. The value of the experience is not inherent, I think, but found in your personal relationship to the album and the way you approach the opportunity to really listen. That might explain why I saw a broad spectrum of reactions as I was leaving: many people looked deeply affected as we filed out of the planetarium, some almost reverent, while a few appeared disappointed.
When I listen to the album now, I feel my listening has been genuinely enriched. According to Gomori, that effect isn't limited to Pitchblack's events: "I find myself increasingly at gigs and clubs closing my eyes, and I'm just like, 'Oh my God, this is so much better,'" he told me. "It instantly becomes so much more intense and visceral, in a way ... It just consumes you."
My critical brain struggles to determine what about my experience was owed to the event, and what was simply the brilliance of Joni Mitchell (when I asked Gomori why they selected Hejira for the Space Centre, he said, "She's the queen."), but separating the two might be a fool's errand. It's probably true that I wouldn't have had such an intense reaction had I attended one of the other listening sessions that night instead. But that might not be a design flaw so much as the way taste operates.
It's certainly special to listen to music in a communal setting, and yes, the surround sound in the planetarium is far better than headphones, but that alone isn't enough to justify going out of your way. If you're the sort of person who regularly commits their time and energy to sitting down and listening - really listening - to albums, you may not need to spend money to have an experience similar to mine.
But allow me to be presumptuous for a moment: you are probably not that kind of person. I'm guessing most of the people reading this are more like me, throwing on an album to soundtrack a commute or study session and discovering new music through streaming algorithms. That's understandable - our time is scant, and our attention is valuable and dwindling fast. Even so, the growing prevalence of disaffected engagement with music is bad for the state of the art form in general, and getting accustomed to music as filler for the background of our lives might preclude listeners from having the aesthetic experience a good album can afford them.
Forcing you to move away from that mode of listening into a clear-eyed, unclouded one is, more than anything, the need that Pitchblack Playback satisfies. "[It's] not that different from what we're asking our audiences to do when they come in here," Unger said. "It's a meditative act to be looking up at the stars, and listening to music is also a meditative act."
In the end, that was the thrill Pitchblack Playback served up to me: not the excitement of a novel event, but the old, familiar thrill of great music.
Printed from the official Joni Mitchell website. Permanent link: https://jonimitchell.com/library/view.cfm?id=6088
Copyright protected material on this website is used in accordance with 'Fair Use', for the purpose of study, review or critical analysis, and will be removed at the request of the copyright owner(s). Please read 'Notice and Procedure for Making Claims of Copyright Infringement' at JoniMitchell.com/legal.cfm