Library of Articles

  • Library: Articles

How many details do famous people owe you about their health? None Print-ready version

by Lorraine Sommerfeld
Hamilton Spectator
April 20, 2015

[John Shearer,The Canadian Press file photo] Joni Mitchell at the 2015 Clive Davis Pre-Grammy Gala at the Beverly Hilton Hotel in Beverly Hills, Calif. this past February.

Joni Mitchell's recent health issues are capturing headlines. Speculation is to be expected when the person in question is an icon.

It was reported she was taken to hospital a few weeks ago, condition unknown. I've watched concern pile up among music lovers and here in my own small heart because Joni Mitchell is, well, Joni Mitchell. Her work stands alone. News of her being unwell reminds me of all the things I take for granted, the things I think about sporadically or intensely or sometimes not at all for long stretches; Joni's music is a friend of mine.

But I also watched one paper publish an opinion piece along the lines of What Joni Has Always Meant to Me that read more like an obituary. I thought that was the height of bad taste until I read another that flat out stated if she was suffering mental health issues, we needed to be told because how else will we ever reduce the stigma if someone like Joni Mitchell won't discuss her personal issues? It made the near-obituary look a wise editorial decision. It wasn't, but there's nothing like terrible to make bad look better.

You've heard of peak oil, the terminal decline in readily available oil, terminology now being applied to water. Have we reached peak garbage yet? Maybe our brains are at last so saturated in nonsense that we can finally stop entertaining ourselves to death and start to have conversations about things that matter. Joni Mitchell is no real housewife, no fame whore kindling notoriety into headlines because talent was just too elusive.

Yet, a newspaper article in one of this country's major players opines she owes us more. She owes us the nitty gritty, down and dirty details of what might be playing out with her health. Specifically, her mental health. Because Mitchell - intensely private - has alluded to struggles in the past, we deserve details. A 75-year-old heavy smoker is taken to hospital; speculate on that if you require fodder. Don't pretend her mental health is about education and information by deciding within a moral vacuum what she owes us.

I talk openly about being bipolar. I spill pretty much everything if I think it might nudge others to find help, or gain a little empathy. I live out loud, but never in a million years do I think anyone else is obliged to. You don't demand someone share details of their life because you think it's the right thing to do. You don't get to decide that Joni Mitchell owes you anything.

I love when people say they're just tryin' to reduce the stigma, helpful little busybodies that they are. Discussing an individual's mental health in a conversation they are not participating in is not about boosting awareness, it's about chasing ratings. There's stigma about a lot of things, like adultery or hemorrhoids. By a certain age, you've probably dealt with one of them. Shall we speculate, so we can remove the stigma? Care to have people publicly debate your association with either of those topics?

Car manufacturers have started making something they call "infotainment" systems. It's a horrible word, colliding information and entertainment as if we're too stupid to be able to process one without the other. At least they're just trying to physically maximize space with the idea. I'm tired of news sources hiding behind a veneer of advocacy that is simply sensationalism, little "info" to go with the "tainment."

Before you take part in this kind of speculation, first decide what you would owe a bunch of strangers.

Copyright protected material on this website is used in accordance with 'Fair Use', for the purpose of study, review or critical analysis, and will be removed at the request of the copyright owner(s). Please read Notice and Procedure for Making Claims of Copyright Infringement.

Added to Library on April 20, 2015. (4562)

Comments:

Log in to make a comment

janelleswenson on

MORGELLONS INBLOOM
My sister died from pills and morgellons on 4-11-14 one year ago. She Joleen lived and died alone except for the love of Christ, with sores all over her body a thousand miles away from me.
I was wondering if Joni ever felt she had possibly been 'targetted' for morgellons too.
My sister came down with morgies right after I came out of the closet against the 'common core' and the homosexual lobby.
Our 'school' where I use to work, is under occupy by politically active Zionists and their 'community center' with a new 'community health clinic' funded by Bill Gates that sits on our campus and wants to shoot us up with poisions. This group is presently strangleing us intellectually and spiritually and killing us with their vaccines and pc propaganda and I had been brave enough to come out against it...
Joni recently had identified and outed Bob zimmerman's legendary musical talent as being un-authentic like his name.
My sister died a terrible death, sad, lonely and un-heard except for me, but I was too afraid to help her cause: morgellons. The world would abandon her to her 'mental illness' and her pills.
She was sad and over-whelmed because our younger sister had recently "committed suiside" with pills and booze, even tho she was rich, gorgeous and loved life.
She " suisided" on 9-11 the ten year anniverary, soon after I had come out with a comic book called 'When Heather's in Bloom' and let Heather see it in Dec 2011.
In Dec 2011 I turned Heather (an adult Jewish princess BULLY teacher at the community center) on campus into a comicbook charactor because I wanted to introduce her to Christ. I planted her in my back yard garden and watered her with sciptures from the Bible. She grew. She shopped me to the principle and I got fired three later for anti-semitism and anti-homosexualy- in 2014 when I fully came out of the closet for the above mentioned.
Bill Gates and friends changed the name of their private thinktank the 'Shared Learning Collaberative' to INBloom Inc. in May 2012, in hopes of gleaning child data for profit encluding our school who were then already volentarily testing the common core in 2012, which common core is privately ownd by a few men (aquainted with our school). After huge parent uproar over their school kids in the new INBOOM CLOUD, Bill Gates was forced somehow to shut down his multi million dollar company-InBLoom Inc.
My sister and I knew that if Joni Mitchell had morgies and was brave enough to admitt to it, the world would believe her and that the condition is real after all. Morgellons as real as Joni Mitchell is brave.
Morgellons: an air-born vacination to remedy bravery.
Please give this info to Joni. She was everything to me as a child of 14. I can't say where I am or who I am. The info I have given is for Joni only. Its too dangerous for my living relatives please don't paste it on-line.