FORUM  [back to list of discussions]    

Banshee on Nathan La Franeer

All times are GMT-5

juanmoth   2009-Oct-25 at 13:44:20
Can anyone shed any light on what a banshee is? I spent an afternoon googling it and didn't find anything conclusive. The consensus is that it's some sort of talk-box effects pedal for a guitar (used most prominently by Peter Frampton, Aerosmith & Joe Walsh in the 70s), but to me that seems unlikely, since the banshee of NLF doesn't sound anything like the talking electric guitar. My hunch is that it's some sort of homemade instrument, either a siren-like aerophone or a hurdy gurdy. Anyway, I'd be immensely grateful if anyone could share what they know about this. I find the dissonance it provides on Nathan La Franeer to be a surprisingly avant element.


sweet.bird   2009-Oct-30 at 12:11:12
i've also googled it, and yes... the talk-box is coming up.
by the sounds of it, it's a pre-amp... and i'm assuming they just reverbed it (maybe not a good choice of words, but i can't think of anything else at the moment) or tweaked it to have a sound such as on NLF come out.

thanks, honestly for mentioning this... as i was listening to NLF yesterday, i was taking notice of the banshee and just hearing how distinct it is in the track. i really do enjoy it.


davidmartin   2009-Oct-30 at 16:57:18
I have always wondered about it too. Is it possible that it is not the name of the instrument but refers to the imagined wailing sound of the Irish myth? I listened to it again and it sounds like it could be a harmonica.
If you watch the 1984 George C. Scott version of "A Christmas Carol", you will hear the exact same sound when one of the scary spirits visits Scrooge.




Discussion topics


Title (responses) Date started (GMT-5)
» maidstone, sk, girl (no responses)     2009-Nov-14 at 23:15.03     
» To Joni (no responses)     2009-Nov-14 at 10:05.05     
» drunk druff (no responses)     2009-Nov-13 at 17:54.15     
» Interesting book about music and the brain (no responses)     2009-Nov-11 at 14:07.23     
» Wally Breese (2)     2009-Nov-11 at 06:34.40     
» just a drop in (no responses)     2009-Nov-10 at 15:25.20     
» A Woman Of Heart And Mind (no responses)     2009-Nov-09 at 16:55.13     
» Finding good music to listen to (14)     2009-Nov-08 at 17:55.29     
» Joni's orchestral music (7)     2009-Nov-07 at 09:18.16     
» HAPPY BIRTHDAY, JONI! (4)     2009-Nov-04 at 17:40.35     
» Spotted the Blonde Goddess @ LAX (5)     2009-Nov-03 at 20:18.30     
» When was the last time she performed live? (2)     2009-Nov-01 at 12:02.43     
» Thoughts on "Shine" (22)     2009-Nov-01 at 06:08.07     
» "Love" on Travelogue and "Both Sides Now" (3)     2009-Nov-01 at 05:15.36     
» Amchitka Concert (2)     2009-Oct-31 at 18:56.37     
» children?? (2)     2009-Oct-31 at 17:29.30     
» Joni, her health, and care (no responses)     2009-Oct-31 at 17:19.43     
» Hissing of Lawns, Darkness (no responses)     2009-Oct-31 at 03:21.16     
» Banshee on Nathan La Franeer (2)     2009-Oct-25 at 13:44.20     
» unusual guitar used on Come in from the Cold video (2)     2009-Oct-23 at 22:22.35     
» 180 Gram Vinyl (2)     2009-Oct-23 at 10:55.43     
» oh joni. (1)     2009-Oct-21 at 13:27.12     
» demos or acoustic versions? (5)     2009-Oct-14 at 21:20.02     
» Lara Fabian present her TRibute EWIM (2)     2009-Oct-09 at 16:22.50     
» Joni MItchell and Videogames (1)     2009-Oct-09 at 16:15.12     
» Video (1)     2009-Sep-25 at 06:24.34     
» is a box set happening???? (6)     2009-Sep-21 at 18:09.08     
» Joni on Wogan in 1987 on YouTube (1)     2009-Sep-21 at 12:08.38     
» Joni Mitchell Mentioned (no responses)     2009-Sep-18 at 15:27.54     
» Joni's performance of California Oct. 9, 1970 (1)     2009-Sep-16 at 15:01.33     
» A tribute to Joni (no responses)     2009-Sep-15 at 04:33.37     
» Joni Mitchell Original Art for Sale--Need to Sell my Joni Bowl (no responses)     2009-Sep-13 at 09:21.35     
» Need to Sell My "Joni Bowl" (no responses)     2009-Sep-10 at 21:07.39     
» Remixing Joni..? (2)     2009-Sep-09 at 15:24.44     
» Biography (no responses)     2009-Sep-05 at 03:43.14     
» The Jungle Line (no responses)     2009-Sep-04 at 01:01.57     
» I think van Gogh looks like macaroni art (no responses)     2009-Sep-02 at 21:42.17     
» HITS & MISSES COVER PHOTOS (3)     2009-Aug-31 at 12:09.25     
» Setlist archive online? (1)     2009-Aug-30 at 17:32.56     
» Please help me ID this song (1)     2009-Aug-29 at 18:54.12     
» Fundraising for this website (10)     2009-Aug-23 at 07:59.09     
» Joni (no responses)     2009-Aug-20 at 18:57.33     
» Miles of Aisles cover location (2)     2009-Aug-18 at 16:06.52     
» why are there no new protest songs. we need help (no responses)     2009-Aug-17 at 16:35.47     
» Stickleback Fish (no responses)     2009-Aug-13 at 10:19.22     
» I need to sell my joni painting (15)     2009-Aug-07 at 12:12.47     
» Todd Rundgren riffs Joni? (no responses)     2009-Aug-04 at 15:43.47     
» Keep focused people (no responses)     2009-Aug-04 at 01:16.27     
» Lets keep the forum focused on Joni's music and art (2)     2009-Aug-04 at 01:14.24     
» Big Music vs its own cusfomers (1)     2009-Aug-02 at 13:25.53     
» A Message for Joni (no responses)     2009-Jul-26 at 00:44.05     
» the song that lives with me.. (3)     2009-Jul-18 at 16:17.54     
» Genius at three....... (no responses)     2009-Jul-17 at 20:37.16     
» Reflections on "A Child Came Out to Wander," (no responses)     2009-Jul-15 at 20:01.06     
» SHINE! (1)     2009-Jul-09 at 21:37.55     
» Sweet Bird (3)     2009-Jul-09 at 11:25.51     
» Joni Mitchell Tribute Concert, Sydney Opera House, Australia (2)     2009-Jul-08 at 13:31.01     
» Thanks for the site. (no responses)     2009-Jul-05 at 09:45.19     
» Cover of Shine (2)     2009-Jul-01 at 13:57.15     
» What do you think about life extension (1)     2009-Jun-27 at 23:37.55     
» the new box set!!!! (5)     2009-Jun-26 at 23:43.25     
» "Both Sides Now" Tour Lithos (autographed and otherwise) (no responses)     2009-Jun-21 at 10:48.22     
» a song for Iran (no responses)     2009-Jun-21 at 10:47.57     
» Cosmic dreamer star date June 14 2009 (no responses)     2009-Jun-17 at 02:40.52     
» Everything for Nothing (12)     2009-Jun-15 at 21:18.08     
» Two Gray Rooms (3)     2009-Jun-15 at 21:16.46     
» Fan Mail Address? (1)     2009-May-30 at 19:44.45     
» " For The Roses ~ (2)     2009-May-27 at 17:52.49     
» Sampling "A case of You" (1)     2009-May-24 at 16:52.08     
» Music only for Woodstck song? (no responses)     2009-May-23 at 19:47.30     
» WBAI-FM BENEFIT Joni Photo 11"x14" signed by Henry Diltz (no responses)     2009-May-22 at 16:30.39     
» Big yelllow taxi origin (2)     2009-May-16 at 06:23.39     
» dont step on jonis toes!!!!!!!!!! (1)     2009-May-15 at 10:25.45     
» Joni Mitchell: An Honor to Meet the Icon (5)     2009-May-13 at 10:32.46     
» Message from Costa Rica (1)     2009-Apr-22 at 22:39.09     
» Come In From The Cold: On DVD??? (3)     2009-Apr-18 at 06:52.07     
» Did Joni plagarize Camus? (16)     2009-Apr-13 at 21:46.25     
» What is Joni`s best song? (41)     2009-Apr-12 at 02:09.57     
» What is Joni`s best album? (21)     2009-Apr-11 at 14:04.53     
» Joni References in Motorsport Journalism (1)     2009-Apr-11 at 08:02.43     
» "Will You Take Me as I Am" (3)     2009-Apr-10 at 11:37.45     
» How about some live joni in the uk? (6)     2009-Apr-09 at 12:58.53     
» tracks in the grooves of reality (4)     2009-Apr-07 at 23:47.16     
» Love (4)     2009-Apr-07 at 14:23.51     
» French fans (4)     2009-Apr-07 at 11:30.43     
» Nomination for George Gershwin Award (4)     2009-Apr-06 at 14:52.45     
» From Bessie to.... (1)     2009-Apr-04 at 14:10.46     
» "Consider a Donation" (7)     2009-Apr-03 at 12:55.15     
» April Fool joke (2)     2009-Apr-03 at 07:24.34     
» Joni Art (3)     2009-Apr-03 at 02:12.10     
» Morgellons diesease? (3)     2009-Apr-02 at 15:50.30     
» Is Joni ever gonna come to Spain? (6)     2009-Apr-02 at 09:13.59     

Search the forum